Updated 2026/09/12
The Best Pie shops in United States (2026)
Compare 130 pie shops in United States, averaging 4.59 stars on Google Maps. The typical listing has 363 reviews, so the ratings below reflect real customer volume rather than a handful of opinions. 88% maintain a website. Most are clustered around Greenwood, Park Slope, Ridgecrest. Rankings combine Google rating, review volume and website popularity, keep one entry per brand, and refresh automatically as our data updates.
Top picks
Ashleigh's Bakeshop
115 Westport Rd, Kansas City, MO 64111
Piefalootin
Cheery fixture for pies by the slice
Birdie's Pie Shop - Post Falls
Serving hand-crafted dessert and savory pies to Post Falls, Coeur d'Alene, Hayden, Birdie's Pie Shop is a dedicated, pie-only bakery with personal pies, bite-sized pies and large 11" pies made daily for dine-in and take-out. We have limited seating inside and a delicious pie patio for comfotable out
Morrison's Fried Pies
We are a small family business making homemade fried pies. We use fresh ingredients, so no additives, preservatives, or food colorings and we NEVER sell day olds so everything is always fresh!
The Pie Chest
Cozy pie shop for gourmet bites
The Happy Apple Pie Shop
Hand crafted sweet and savory pies using locally sourced fruit and vegetables. Social enterprise with a blended workforce of people with and without disabilities.
Proper Pie Co.
Sweet & savory treats in a cozy bakeshop
Pie Junkie
Pie shop with classic & creative flavors
J. J. Gandy's Pies, Inc.
Since 1982, JJ Gandy’s Pies has proudly served the Palm Harbor community with homemade pies, cookies, and freshly baked desserts. For more than 40 years, we've been known for our famous Key Lime Pie, signature Key Lime Cookies, and delicious Orange Cookies, all made with quality ingredients and time
Southern Pie Cafe
Small cafe on the beautiful historic green in Chester VT. We serve breakfast, coffee , lunch, ice cream and of course or made from scratch unique delicious PIES!
Full list
Frequently asked questions
How many pie shops are there in United States?
We list 130 pie shops in United States that meet our quality bar of at least 4.0 stars and 10 Google reviews. The wider directory holds more, including newer and unrated businesses.
Which pie shop in United States is rated highest?
Ashleigh's Bakeshop currently tops our list with 5.0 stars from 277 reviews. Rankings update as new reviews and traffic data arrive.
How are the pie shops ranked?
Each business gets a composite score: 70% a Bayesian average of its Google rating and review count, so a 4.9-star business with hundreds of reviews outranks a 5.0 with five, and 30% estimated website traffic. Chains appear once. Nobody can pay to be listed or ranked.