Updated 2026/09/12

The Best Pizza restaurants in Newburgh, United States (2026)

Compare 31 pizza restaurants in Newburgh, United States, averaging 4.43 stars on Google Maps. The typical listing has 325 reviews, so the ratings below reflect real customer volume rather than a handful of opinions. 97% maintain a website. Most are clustered around Gardnertown, New Windsor, Vails Gate. Rankings combine Google rating, review volume and website popularity, keep one entry per brand, and refresh automatically as our data updates.

31 businesses ranked4.43 average rating

Top picks

Rank 1
C

Cinema Pizza

4.7(142)
54.4

215 Quassaick Ave #105, New Windsor, NY 12553

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 2

Cascarino's

4.6(923)
49.3

Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 3

Cold Spring Pizza

4.6(569)
49.2

Counter-serve stop for pies & slices

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 4
L

Lillo's Pizza

4.6(70)
47.7

67 Main St #1824, Walden, NY 12586

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 5

Cosimo's

4.5(2079)
42.5

Casual Italian spot for pizzas & more

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website 1
Rank 6

Joe's Pizza & Deli

4.5(678)
42.5

198 S Plank Rd, Newburgh, NY 12550

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 7

Florina’s Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta

4.5(443)
42.5

Pizzeria and Italian restaurant

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 8

Domenico's Pizzeria

4.5(351)
42.5

At Domenico’s Pizzeria, pizza is more than food — it’s family, it’s tradition, and it’s the way we bring people together. Inspired by classic Italian roots and a love for honest, handmade food, we’ve built a place where everyone feels welcome and every bite tastes like home. Our dough is crafted fr

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 9

Capri Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.5(330)
42.5

Relaxed option for Italian dining

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website
Rank 10

Pizza & Stuff

4.5(327)
42.5

Basic joint for pies, subs & pasta

Pizza restaurantNewburgh Website 1

How we rank

  • Google rating and review volume, as a Bayesian average, so a 4.9 with 500 reviews outranks a 5.0 with five.
  • Website popularity: estimated monthly visits, an independent signal of real-world demand.
  • Only businesses with at least 4.0 stars and 10 reviews qualify, and each brand appears once.
  • Rankings recompute automatically as our data refreshes. No business can pay to be listed or ranked higher.

Full list

11Joe Cristiano's Pizza4.4(129)12Giuseppe's4.4(173)13Eddie's Gourmet Pizza4.4(169)14Angelina's4.4(162)15Laby's Pizzeria4.4(194)16Pizza Heaven4.4(293)17Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery4.4(348)18Primo's Pizza4.4(345)19Sal's Pizza & Pasta4.4(325)20Midway's Villa Roma4.4(304)21Enoteca Ama4.4(302)22Sal's Pizza & Pasta4.4(448)23Prima Pizza4.4(595)24Pizza Mia4.4(592)25Pizza Shop4.4(813)26Tosi’s Pizza4.3(187)27Village Pizzeria4.3(193)28A B C Pizza & Restaurant4.3(232)29Guido's Pizza Parlor4.3(240)30Villa Italia Ristorante4.3(532)
Browse all pizza restaurants in Newburgh, United States in the directory

Frequently asked questions

How many pizza restaurants are there in Newburgh, United States?

We list 31 pizza restaurants in Newburgh, United States that meet our quality bar of at least 4.0 stars and 10 Google reviews. The wider directory holds more, including newer and unrated businesses.

Which pizza restaurant in Newburgh, United States is rated highest?

Cinema Pizza currently tops our list with 4.7 stars from 142 reviews. Rankings update as new reviews and traffic data arrive.

How are the pizza restaurants ranked?

Each business gets a composite score: 70% a Bayesian average of its Google rating and review count, so a 4.9-star business with hundreds of reviews outranks a 5.0 with five, and 30% estimated website traffic. Chains appear once. Nobody can pay to be listed or ranked.

Related lists

Pizza restaurants elsewhere

United States (16488)Brooklyn, United States (122)New York City, United States (112)Washington, United States (97)Manhattan, United States (94)Harrisburg, United States (76)Middletown, United States (73)Portland, United States (71)

All pizza restaurants in the directory →