The Best Pizza restaurants in Randolph, United States (2026)

Sapori d'Italia

4.9(211)

67.5

Family owned and operated

Sara's Pizza Palace Holbrook

4.8(774)

62.8

Laid-back pizzeria with delivery

Lynwood Cafe

4.7(1992)

56.3

Neighborhood bar with a pizza menu

M&S II Pizza

4.7(1397)

56.3

424 US-46, Rockaway, NJ 07866

Anthony's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant

4.7(622)

56.0

Casual, enduring Italian restaurant

274 Spring St, Newton, NJ 07860

Vinny & Son Pizza (Andover)

4.7(255)

55.3

Pizzeria offering takeout and delivery. We offer delicious, affordable catering. Our catering selections are ideal for office meetings, client presentations, parties, and any other occasion that calls for dishes made with our own long-standing recipes, homemade sauces, and fresh ingredients. We Deli

M&S Pizza

4.6(647)

49.2

Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salads, wings and more M & S Pizza the Original located at 333 Us Highway 46 in Dover, NJ. M & S Pizza the Original is accepting orders online for takeout. To begin your order simply click on any menu. Enjoy!

Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza

4.6(479)

49.2

Theodora's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant is proud to offer Greek, Italian, and Pizza for dine in, take out or delivery. Theodora's Pizza & Family Restaurant, located at 336 South Main Street in Wharton, NJ, is the perfect place to stop in for lunch or dinner. Conveniently located in Wharton, NJ close

81 NJ-183, Stanhope, NJ 07874