Updated 2026/09/12
The Best Restaurants in Middletown, United States (2026)
Compare 70 restaurants in Middletown, United States, averaging 4.52 stars on Google Maps. The typical listing has 481 reviews, so the ratings below reflect real customer volume rather than a handful of opinions. 79% maintain a website. Most are clustered around Mechanicstown, Red Bank, Goshen. Rankings combine Google rating, review volume and website popularity, keep one entry per brand, and refresh automatically as our data updates.
Top picks

One With Land
One With Land offers a casual and vibrant atmosphere that pairs well with its farm-to-table plates, bio-dynamic wine list, local craft beers and seasonally inspired cocktails. Fun, seasonal, and inventive, the menu celebrates local farms and the bounty of the Hudson Valley region.

Pho & Grill Vietnamese Restaurant
Welcome to the NEW family and local owned Pho & Grill where we focus on fresh and high quality authentic Vietnamese cuisines as prepared by our Grandmother. In addition, we’ve revamped the drinks menu with fresh ingredients that will satisfy the most discriminating customers. Our focus is to delive

Sarah's on Main
246 Main St, Portland, CT 06480
Bud's Cafe
158 Main St # 1, Portland, CT 06480

Numprik Thai Lao
Snug spot for Thai & Laotian chow

First State Brewing Company
First State Brewing Company is a Delaware craft brewery, taproom and restaurant in Middletown. Enjoy fresh, locally brewed beer—including hazy and West Coast IPAs, crisp pilsners and rotating seasonal releases—alongside a creative American food menu, cocktails and more. Our spacious Brewery + Kitche

Olive Falafel
670 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10941

Lenora's Cafe
BYOB

Las Mañanitas Mexican
158 Sullivan St, Wurtsboro, NY 12790

Grill 36
Mediterranean takeout restaurant
Full list
Frequently asked questions
How many restaurants are there in Middletown, United States?
We list 70 restaurants in Middletown, United States that meet our quality bar of at least 4.0 stars and 10 Google reviews. The wider directory holds more, including newer and unrated businesses.
Which restaurant in Middletown, United States is rated highest?
One With Land currently tops our list with 4.8 stars from 602 reviews. Rankings update as new reviews and traffic data arrive.
How are the restaurants ranked?
Each business gets a composite score: 70% a Bayesian average of its Google rating and review count, so a 4.9-star business with hundreds of reviews outranks a 5.0 with five, and 30% estimated website traffic. Chains appear once. Nobody can pay to be listed or ranked.